Port Aransas Conservancy

Port Aransas ConservancyPort Aransas ConservancyPort Aransas Conservancy

Port Aransas Conservancy

Port Aransas ConservancyPort Aransas ConservancyPort Aransas Conservancy
  • Home
  • Overview
  • Donate
  • Top 20 Concerns
  • Desalination Plant
  • Harbor Island Terminal
  • PCCA's VLCC Terminal
  • Lone Star Ports
  • Axis @ USACE
  • Axis @ TCEQ
  • Bluewater Texas
  • 54' CCCIP
  • 75' Dredging
  • Restrictive Covenant
  • TGTI Terminal
  • Offshore Ports
  • Petition
  • Legislators
  • Deeport
  • Environment
  • Oil Industry News
  • News
  • More News
  • News Archive
  • Resources
  • More Resources
  • Newsletter Archive
  • About Us
  • More
    • Home
    • Overview
    • Donate
    • Top 20 Concerns
    • Desalination Plant
    • Harbor Island Terminal
    • PCCA's VLCC Terminal
    • Lone Star Ports
    • Axis @ USACE
    • Axis @ TCEQ
    • Bluewater Texas
    • 54' CCCIP
    • 75' Dredging
    • Restrictive Covenant
    • TGTI Terminal
    • Offshore Ports
    • Petition
    • Legislators
    • Deeport
    • Environment
    • Oil Industry News
    • News
    • More News
    • News Archive
    • Resources
    • More Resources
    • Newsletter Archive
    • About Us
  • Home
  • Overview
  • Donate
  • Top 20 Concerns
  • Desalination Plant
  • Harbor Island Terminal
  • PCCA's VLCC Terminal
  • Lone Star Ports
  • Axis @ USACE
  • Axis @ TCEQ
  • Bluewater Texas
  • 54' CCCIP
  • 75' Dredging
  • Restrictive Covenant
  • TGTI Terminal
  • Offshore Ports
  • Petition
  • Legislators
  • Deeport
  • Environment
  • Oil Industry News
  • News
  • More News
  • News Archive
  • Resources
  • More Resources
  • Newsletter Archive
  • About Us

the problems with a desalination plant

Harbor Island Desalination Plant

TCEQ Draft Permit

The Port of Corpus Christi Authority (PCCA) has proposed a major desalination plant on Harbor Island. Because of the large volume of negative comments the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) referred the matter to the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH), which recently concluded a contentious hearing in which PAC and numerous private parties argued that the permit application should be denied.  The judges will issue their recommendation by February 5, 2021. Then the matter goes to the TCEQ commissioners for a final decision, which is likely to occur in March or April 2021.


"The TCEQ executive director has completed the technical review of the application and prepared a draft permit." 


Despite the studies we submitted showing the ecological damage that this plant would entail TCEQ decided that dumping 95 million gallons per day of hypersaline water into waters next to the estuary wouldn't be a problem:


 "The effluent will be discharged via pipe directly to Corpus Christi Bay in Segment No. 2481 of the Bays and Estuaries. The designated uses for Segment No. 2481 are primary recreation, exceptional aquatic life use, and oyster waters." 


The Port Aransas Conservancy is strongly opposed to POCCA's plans to place a desalination plant on Harbor Island next to the ferry landing and directly across from Roberts Point Park. The plant would discharge up to 95.6 million gallons per day of highly saline effluent into the ship channel; the tides would move this plume into the surrounding wetlands, killing off the spawning grounds for shrimp, crabs, and fish. This project would be an ecological disaster that could drive off the fishing industry and would certainly impact the tourism that supports Port Aransas. We strongly support Mayor Bujan and the city in their opposition to it. 


This project must not go forward.


Desal plant application

Harbor Island Permit Application (pdf)

Download

TCEQ Interim Order (pdf)

Download

desal plant draft permit

TCEQ Basis for Prelim Permit (pdf)Download
TCEQ Draft Permit 5253 (pdf)Download
Desal Plant Design (pdf)Download
Notice of public hearing 7 Sept 2022 (pdf)Download

SOAH desal Hearing pleadings (1 of 2)

PAC's Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
Aligned Pro-Se Protestants' Closing Argument (pdf)Download
OPIC Closing Argument (PDF)Download
Audubon Texas Closing statement (pdf)Download
PCCA's Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
PCCA's Response to Protestants' Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
PAC's Reply to PCCA's Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
PAC's Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (pdf)Download
Executive Director's Reply to Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
Individual Protestants' Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (pdf)Download
PAC's Response to Objections to Testimony on Remand (pdf)Download
PAC's Response to Port's Motion to Exclude (pdf)Download
2022.03.09 Prehearing Statement for Kings and Steves (pdf)Download

SOAH DESAL HEARING PLEADINGS (2 of 2)

PCCA Remand Closing arguments (pdf)Download
OPIC_POCCA Remand Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
Audubon Remand Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
Pro-se Group Remand Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
Kings Steves Remand Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
PAC's Remand Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
ED's Remand Closing Arguments (pdf)Download
PAC's And Kings and Steves' Reply to Closing Arguments on Remand (Final) (pdf)Download
PAC's and Kings and Steves' Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on Remand.docx (Final) (pdf)Download
June 2022 ALJ Recommendations to TCEQ (pdf)Download
PAC Original Petition for Judicial Review (pdf)Download

Testimony of PAC's Experts

PAC-44R - Remand Prefiled Testimony of Barney Austin (pdf)Download
PAC-45R Remand Prefiled Testimony of Andrew Esbaugh (pdf)Download
PAC-46R Remand Prefiled Testimony of Scott Holt (pdf)Download
PAC-47R Remand Prefiled Testimony of Larry McKinney (pdf)Download
PAC-48R Remand Prefiled Testimony of Kristin Nielsen (pdf)Download
PAC-49R - Remand Prefiled Testimony of Tim Osting (pdf)Download
PAC-50R - Remand Prefiled Testimony of Daniel Schlenk (pdf)Download
PAC-51R Remand Prefiled Testimony of Scott Socolofsky (pdf)Download
PAC-52R Remand Prefiled Testimony of Greg Stunz (pdf)Download
PAC-53R Remand Prefiled Testiomony of Bruce Wiland (pdf)Download

EPA Letters

9_2_22 Corpus Christi Community letter draft AE RR Nance_Final signed (pdf)Download
9_2_22 TCEQ Chairman Letter Final (pdf)Download
EPA_Response_to_TCEQ_Jan_31_2022_Letter_SIGNED_03012022 (pdf)Download
POCC Desal Permit_Interim Objection Letter_FINAL_12-15-2021-signed (pdf)Download
TX0138347_Port_Corpus_Christi_DESAL FACILITIES_RESCIND_WAIVE_09_20_21 (pdf)Download
OrderPermit 2019-1156-IWD (optimized) (pdf)Download
POCC Desal Permit_Interim Objection Letter_FINAL_12-15-2021-signed (pdf)Download
TCEQ TPDES Letter 1 19 2023 signed (pdf)Download

Marine Science Literature for Desalinization & Channel Deepening Projects

Scientific articles regarding desalination and channel dredging courtesy of the University of Texas Marine Science Institute.

Find out more

more scientific papers

Larvae of estuarine dependent species Buskey (docx)

Download

Desal Intake Discharge Report (pdf)

Download

Resources

TCEQ Notice of Preliminary Decision (pdf)

Download

Notice of Receipt and Intent to Obain WQ Permit WQ0005253000 (pdf)

Download

Desalination Plants: Potential impacts of brine discharge on marine life (pdf)

Download

Environmental Impact and Impact Assessment of Desalination (pdf)

Download

Effects of a Desalination Plant Discharge on the Marine Environment of Barrow Island (pdf)

Download

Impacts of Brine Discharge on the Marine Environment (pdf)

Download

Desalination Intake Investigation (pdf)

Download

Desalination Technology Trends (pdf)

Download

An Overview of Seawater Intake Facilities for Seawater Desalination (pdf)

Download

Water Desalination (pdf)

Download

Water Desalination in Texas (pdf)

Download

The Future of Desalination in Texas (pdf)

Download

Desalination: Is It Worth the Salt? (pdf)

Download

Photo Gallery

1/5

Copyright © 2018-2023 Port Aransas Conservancy  - All Rights Reserved.